Azeroth = Disney World

Option 1: Criticism

I chose to read and analyze the essay, “A Hollow World: World of Warcraft as Spatial Practice” by Espen Aarseth, from Digital Culture, Play, and Identity: A “World of Warcraft” Reader. Aarseth primarily focuses on how Azeroth and the world of World of Warcraft relates to other game worlds and other fictitious worlds, as well as the real world. When World of Warcraft (2004) is compared to the first-person 3D perspective of Everquest (1999) and Everquest 2 (2004), there are several similarities and differences between the two game worlds. Warcraft was released after both of these games and many other MMOGs so Blizzard Entertainment was able to learn from the failures and successes experienced by other games before their own release. Warcraft has rather flat, cartoonish artwork whereas Everquest 2 utilized photorealistic, high-resolution graphics. This affects the gameplay throughout the world significantly because the characters cannot move across the world as fluently or continuously as one can navigate the semi unified Azeroth. Instead, players are forced to navigate a labyrinth of connected game levels in Everquest 2. 

Aarseth continues by comparing Azeroth to the fictional fantasy world of Middle-earth in Tolkien’s The Lord of The Rings. Middle-earth is an extremely expansive world where Minas Tirith, the human city, is 200 miles away from Sauron, the dark lord, and 450 miles away from Saruman, the powerful wizard. It is not a problem that Middle-earth is so big though because there can be gaps in the reading where the reader jumps to another scene and they do not have to read about the same character walking hundreds of miles. This is an advantage of fictitious worlds in books and movies.

Finally Aarseth relates Azeroth to the real world. This is most easily done by giving people a well-known point of reference that they can compare the size to. The Eastern Kingdom is about 8 miles long (as determined by mapwow.com) and takes 3-4 hours to traverse from one end to the other. This is comparable to the island of Manhattan, which is just shy of 8 miles long. This really surprised me at first because when playing the game, the world seems so much larger than Manhattan due to all of the differing regions and physical landscapes. This is what leads Aarseth to his final argument that Azeroth is most closely related to a theme park or zoo. Florida’s Disney World is fifty square miles, which makes it comparable to Azeroth not only in size, but also in purpose. As Aarseth states, “Both contain different thematic zones connected by paths, roads, and rail-based transportation, which cater to differing tastes, age groups, or levels.”

I agree with Aarseth’s argument in that Azeroth is most comparable to a theme park or zoo. While I have been playing World of Warcraft, I had not considered the game world very closely as I have only been focused on completing quests and leveling up quickly for class. However, after reading “A Hollow World: World of Warcraft as Spatial Practice”, I have actually had time to stop and think about the game world as a whole. In my experience, I have certainly not played a game with a world as large as Azeroth. However, it makes sense that there must be a happy medium between a playable, user-friendly world and a fictitious fantasy world like Middle-earth. There would be no way to traverse Middle-earth in a game because all of the game playtime would be spent traveling to the next town.

This has helped me realize that Azeroth is extremely similar to Disney World in several different ways. The first obvious similarity is the proximity of so many varying regions and themes within one place. In Disneyworld, one can easily travel from downtown Disney to Blizzard Beach Water Park to Animal Kingdom to the Magic Kingdom via the established paths throughout the park. Whereas in Warcraft, one can easily travel from Elwynn Forest to Westfall to Duskwood to the Redridge Mountains all by foot. Each of these areas is extremely different from one another with regards to climate, landscape, and the beings that you will encounter there but you are still able to get from one to another incredibly easily. These regions can be viewed in the maps below. A second similarity between Azeroth and Disney World is that there are only certain areas that a person can enter. In Disney World, there are rides that you must be a certain height in order to ride and if you are not that height, then you are unable to ride that ride. Additionally there are areas that can only be entered by employees and cannot be accessed by visitors. In Azeroth, you must reach a certain level before you can enter some areas otherwise you will be killed by more advanced enemies. In both cases the higher-level people are able to enter the lower level areas but they will not be as exciting or challenging to them. Finally, these different regions that are rated for different levels of experience are divided. At Disney World the regions are divided by fences and other obstacles and in Warcraft they are divided by mountain ranges and rivers that cannot be crossed.

Azeroth

Map_WDW_Resort

Aarseth did a great analysis on the world of World of Warcraft. He made many valid points that reasoned why Azeroth is the way it is. Additionally, he used easy-to-understand comparisons that most people will recognize immediately such as Manhattan, Middle-earth, and Disney World. However, he primarily focuses on the Eastern Kingdom, which was good since I just started playing but I would had liked to see him touch on Kalimdor, Northrend, and Pandaria because these places are very mysterious to me.

Works Cited

Aarseth, Espen. “A Hollow World: World of Warcraft as Spatial Practice.” Digital Culture, Play, and Identity: A “World of Warcraft” Reader. Ed. Hilde G. Corneliussen, Jill Walker Rettberg. Cambridge: The MIT Press, 2008. 111-122. Print.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Reading Response, World of Warcraft and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Azeroth = Disney World

  1. KeepCalm22 says:

    I agree with your analysis of Warcraft as similar to a Disney theme park, a view I never would have thought of before! I find this especially true since the various parks within Disney do not flow, one into the other. You know the minute Animal Kingdom ends and Blizzard Beach begins. It’s like that in a lot of ways in Warcraft. Simply crossing a border leads you from a summery forest to snowy mountains, and populated areas are staged in very concise spaces that are spread out pretty evenly in the Eastern Kingdom. As you enter new areas, you are just as much of a tourist as the average fanny pack-clad person walking through Disney, exploring entirely new environments every time you cross one of the borders from one area to another. To be honest, perhaps Warcraft, in a lot of ways, is also just as overpriced as Disney itself (but that’s just my personal opinion).

    Like

  2. newtonscradle7 says:

    Interesting comparison! I agree that WoW is like Disney, especially in the sense of exploring. It seems like just trying to navigate Disney to get to a ride is like trying to follow the arrow pointing you to a quest in WoW. I guess that would be a big help at Disney, so easy to get lost. I was there for New Years and a heartstone to take me back to my car would’ve definitely helped. In terms of the different levels for access, I agree. It takes until level 20 to be able to ride a horse, and I compare that to having to get a fast pass to be able to use the faster line. This is a great comparison and I agree with KeepCalm22 that WoW is also just an overpriced Disney.

    Like

  3. riderphilze says:

    And quests are like rides, banks are like storage lockers, shops are like the places that gouge you for merchandise, and you never seem to have enough room in your bag to fit all the crap you somehow end up with, do you? You’re less likely to be attacked by murlocs and gnolls in Disney World, at least, though there are all of those mascots running around. The costume actors as NPCs, look at that! If you talk to them you can get loot like hugs, autographs, and photos… this rabbit hole goes way too deep.
    Two big differences I can see are that I’m usually able to walk around Disney World and still enjoy it for longer stretches than I can Azeroth, and I find it much easier to be friendly to Disney’s native fauna.

    Like

  4. burgleyourturts says:

    Would have never thought to compare Disney World to Warcraft and I was mostly skeptical with where you were taking it at first. Then you got to the part where you compared required levels for certain areas in Azeroth to height requirements for certain rides in Disney (to which I actually laughed audibly) but I must admit it was a pretty cool and thought provoking parallel. Much like how running through lower level areas as a higher level character is just boring, ridding kiddy rides can be rather unsatisfying for us big kids. I’m still trying to think of a WoW version of a fastpass….

    Like

  5. smaugonthewater says:

    I really like your comparisons of Disney and Azeroth, certainly not something I would think of. I would like to think that Azeroth is more than just 8 miles and it’s just a compression to be represented in the game. I could also see the different continents as the different Disney locations, like California, Florida, France, and Asia.

    Like

  6. raddishspirit says:

    I like the comparison to Disney World or a theme park as much as the next person, but I feel like it only works for the geographical map of the area. All of the other parts of the game (dungeon, Play, etc) have no analogy to a theme park. There are ways in which the game world differs from that of the real world.

    Like

  7. Pingback: Forgotten Corners of World of Warcraft | Teknoids News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s